Raya and the Last Dragon: An Ancient Story with Modern Lingo

By W. R. Miller on March 9, 2021

In Martin Goodman’s review of Raya and the Last Dragon at Animation Scoop, he makes the observation,

This movie is set in some mishmash of ancient East Asia and the time is not contemporary to ours (I didn’t see any modern architecture, weapons, iPhones, or any vehicles save for what looks to be a giant rolling pangolin), but too much of the dialogue is in 2021 lingo, lending a bizarre tonal contrast to the visuals. One of the worst offenders is Sisu; Awkwafina’s performance is truly fine, but her lines diminish the character; she might as well be playing herself. Maybe Disney does this to chum up to the older kids and tweens; I for one hate it.

A good point. Is it really worth spending so much time, money and effort to depict ancient civilizations to service the story, so audiences can lose themselves in this marvelous past, only to blow this illusion with hip dialog?

Bill Hunt of The Digital Bits notes,

When the film introduces its characters—and the terrific vocal talent here begins to establish itself—the story quickly picks up steam. Unfortunately, that momentum grinds to a halt again briefly when Sisu and Boun (the latter voiced by Izaac Wang) appear, because their dialogue is presented in a contemporary, improvisational style that feels completely out of place with the rest of the film. Clearly, the producers were trying to capture a bit of that old ‘Robin Williams in Aladdin’ magic, but that approach is very hit-or-miss.

The character of Raya, it seems, was influenced by Hayao Miyazaki’s Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind. All right, let’s compare with Miyazaki’s oeuvre–Spirited Away, Laputa, Princess Mononoke, Howl’s Moving Castle. What’s the difference? No hipspeak.

Disney filmmakers may claim reverence for Miyazaki’s works, even superficially borrow some elements, but fail to apply his storytelling ethic.

Here’s an Honest Trailer that also references “2010s banter” (3:40):

Note the “timeless” dialog in the following clip:

“We were doing a jumpy thing.” “My bad.” “I get it, now.” “I’m with it.”

https://youtu.be/4IyRqlBcyeM

Share:
Posted in Animation, Dragons, News | Tagged Animation Scoop, Awkwafina, Bill Hunt, Digital Voice, Hayao Miyazaki, Martin Goodman, Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind, Raya and the Last Dragon
Previous Entry: How to Hug Your Kangaroo
Next Entry: The Passing of Cliff Simon


Subscribe

  • I’m on PBS!

  • THE UNOFFICIAL BATMAN: THE ANIMATED INTERVIEWS, Volume One now available in paperback!

  • Watchtower Database plugs BATMAN: THE ANIMATED INTERVIEWS!

  • Over 30 Years in the Making! Now Available: The Unofficial BATMAN: THE ANIMATED INTERVIEWS

  • The End of the DCAU

  • BATMAN: THE ANIMATED INTERVIEWS–The BearManor Media Interview

  • Update on BATMAN: THE ANIMATED INTERVIEWS

  • Daniel Middleton visits Dagobah

  • Praise for BATMAN: THE ANIMATED INTERVIEWS

  • The May the Fourth Hoax

  • More Entertaining Than STAR TREK: DISCOVERY!

  • The Music of THE EMPIRE STRIKES BACK

  • British Want List

  • Mark Mayerson’s New TRIPP

  • Brad Bird on why the Looney Tunes were successful

  • Dragons of the Day, February 29, 2024

  • Australian Star Wars Articles, Part Four

  • Australian Star Wars Articles, Part Three

  • Australian Star Wars Articles, Part Two

  • Australian Star Wars Articles Want List, Part One

Copyright © 2013-2022 W.R. Miller.